Trader Joe’s is loved for its unique, affordable products and vibrant shopping experience, but even this cult-favorite store has its share of less-than-stellar items.
Despite Trader Joe’s popularity, customers often agree on certain products they’d rather not buy again. From bottled dressings to pre-packaged sushi, here’s a look at seven Trader Joe’s products that customers say just don’t live up to the hype.
1. Buttermilk Ranch Dressing (and Other Bottled Dressings)
Trader Joe’s has an extensive selection of bottled dressings, but not all of them hit the mark. One of the most frequently criticized items is the Buttermilk Ranch Dressing. Customers describe it as “watery” and “sour” with an off-putting flavor that doesn’t live up to traditional buttermilk ranch expectations.
Other dressings, like the Green Goddess, have also received mixed reviews, with some customers calling them “losers.” If you’re a fan of salad dressings, many suggest trying homemade options instead. They’re easy to make, often require only a few ingredients, and allow you to control the flavor.
2. Everything But the Bagel Chips
The Everything but the Bagel seasoning is a staple for many Trader Joe’s shoppers, but the Everything But the Bagel Seasoned Kettle-Cooked Chips didn’t quite win the same fanfare. Customers say these chips have an “overwhelming garlic flavor” that doesn’t resemble everything bagels.
For those craving a tasty Trader Joe’s snack, the Chili & Lime Flavored Rolled Corn Tortilla Chips are highly recommended as an alternative. These chips have a bold, spicy flavor and are frequently praised by fans as one of the best snacks at Trader Joe’s.
3. Cauliflower Gnocchi
The Cauliflower Gnocchi was once celebrated as a healthier alternative to traditional gnocchi, but its texture has left many customers disappointed. Descriptions like “tastes like play-doh” and complaints about its texture being “off” when microwaved or boiled are common.
However, some fans have found that cooking the gnocchi in an air fryer or pan instead of boiling can improve its texture, giving it a crispy outside with a fluffy interior. So if you already have this product, consider experimenting with cooking methods to find a texture you enjoy.
4. Orange Chicken
Trader Joe’s Orange Chicken has been a fan favorite for years, but more recently, customers have noted a drop in quality. According to some shoppers, the sauce has become “bitter” with an unpleasant aftertaste, and the chicken itself can be “stringy” and “overly breaded.”
If you’re a fan of orange chicken, you might enjoy a homemade version or a freshly prepared option from a restaurant instead. Trader Joe’s has also introduced recipes like Orange Chicken & Broccoli Skillet, which could be worth a try if you’re looking for a better flavor experience at home.
5. Pre-Packaged Sushi
Trader Joe’s pre-packaged sushi is one item that often leaves customers with regrets. While the store offers various ready-to-eat sushi options, shoppers describe the rice as having a “horrid texture,” and the overall quality as “so bad.” Many agree that Trader Joe’s sushi doesn’t compare well to fresh options available elsewhere.
Instead of sushi, consider Trader Joe’s frozen rice rolls or kimbap for an alternative in the frozen section. These tend to have better texture and flavor when prepared as instructed.
6. Hearts of Palm Pasta
When Hearts of Palm Pasta first appeared at Trader Joe’s, it quickly went viral, with fans rushing to try it out. However, many were disappointed by its taste and texture, with some saying it “tasted like crunchy weeds” and others describing it as “sour and vile.”
For those looking for veggie-based pasta alternatives, zucchini noodles or spaghetti squash can provide a more satisfying and versatile option. These options are known for their mild taste and flexible texture that better mimics traditional pasta.
7. Cold Brew Coffee Concentrate
Trader Joe’s Cold Brew Coffee Concentrate is another product that doesn’t meet many customers’ expectations. Described as “revolting” by several shoppers, this coffee concentrate is criticized for its unpleasant flavor. Some find the taste so off-putting that they prefer to make their own cold brew at home rather than using this product.
Making homemade cold brew is surprisingly easy and can often yield better results with a smooth, rich flavor that’s lacking in the concentrate. This alternative also allows you to customize the strength and flavor of your cold brew to suit your taste.
What to Do When You Dislike a Trader Joe’s Product
If you’re disappointed with a Trader Joe’s product, you’re not alone, and you don’t need to throw it away. Trader Joe’s has a customer-friendly return policy that allows you to bring back items you didn’t enjoy, even without a receipt for Trader Joe’s branded products.
Just return the item to your local store and let them know about your experience—Trader Joe’s encourages feedback, and they’re known for providing a hassle-free refund.
Final Thoughts
While Trader Joe’s is loved for its unique and affordable selection, there are some items that may not live up to everyone’s expectations.
From Buttermilk Ranch Dressing to Cold Brew Coffee Concentrate, these products have received mixed reviews from customers who have found alternatives they prefer. Fortunately, Trader Joe’s return policy makes it easy to try new things and return items that don’t meet your standards.
Next time you’re shopping at Trader Joe’s, keep these items in mind and consider trying customer-approved favorites instead. And if you ever pick up a product that doesn’t meet your expectations, Trader Joe’s makes it simple to return it, ensuring your shopping experience remains positive and satisfying.